Margery Allingham’s Hide My Eyes

Hide_My_EyesHide My Eyes
Margery Allingham
First published in the UK by Chatto and Windus, 1958
This edition: Penguin Books, 1961
224 pages
Source: My own

This month is 1958 month here at Past Offences. I’m hosting a collection of book and film reviews focusing on the year 1958 – if you want to play, and you’re more than welcome to, please head over to the sign-up page. My 1958 pick was a nice surprise. I thought I had read all of the Margery Allingham Campion novels back in the ’90s – they’re all lined up on my bookshelves – but as soon as I opened my copy of Hide My Eyes, I realised I had somehow neglected to read it. And it’s a cracker.

Hide My Eyes opens in London, in the rain, near Theatreland. A little country bus, complete with two dozing passengers, stops in a dark alley just long enough for the driver to get out and commit a murder. In passing, he spots an elderly lady waiting for a bus home and arranges for a taxi to pick her up. With which strange behaviour, the Goff Place Mystery enters Scotland Yard’s list of unsolved cases.

This book is once again Charlie Luke’s show. Allingham’s series character Albert Campion appears, but is entirely in the background. It is eight months after the Goff Place murder. Luke, now at Scotland Yard, has developed an obsession with a small patch of London called Garden Green. On little evidence but a lot of instinct, he has concluded that the area hosts a multiple murderer. He is so convinced that he has – at the cost of 30 bob – had a direct line to the local police station installed in his office, with instructions to report anything unusual.

Luke is right. The villain of the piece is a nasty piece of work called Gerry Hawker (or something like that – he uses aliases). Gerry is a plausible liar who subsists on the proceeds of crime, but unlike most petty criminals he is not afraid to kill. In common with Jack Havoc in The Tiger in the Smoke, he has a philosophy which he feels makes him impossible to catch. In this paragraph he is talking about women, but he may as well be describing his approach to murder. He is quiet, methodical, and self-contained:

‘Any kind of affection is a solvent. It melts and adulterates the subject and by indulging it he loses his identity and hence his efficiency. By keeping myself to myself in the face of every conceivable attack I have remained successful, bright, and indestructible.’

The theme of Hide My Eyes is wilful blindness, in particular the unwillingness of a mother to see the bad in her son. The ‘mother’ is Polly Tassie, a widow living in Garden Green’s little Museum of Oddities. Polly and her husband ‘adopted’ Gerry during the War. She knows he is bad, but can’t believe he is anything more than misguided, even though she keeps catching him out and her friends advise caution:

‘When one is fond of a son, real, adopted, or step, one has no rules. I know that. One forgives. That is all there is to it, and the whole nature of attachment. That’s life. But, dearest, one still ought to know. One should take common precautions, both for his sake and for one’s own.’

Unlike Jack Havoc, who is almost an anti-hero, Gerry arouses nothing but repulsion in the reader. We follow him over the course of a day’s lies and nefarious activities and he is, genuinely, one of the creepiest baddies I’ve encountered this year. Gerry is accompanied by Richard Waterfield, a young man who has fallen for Polly’s niece Annabelle Tassie and is suspicious enough of Gerry to want to keep an eye on him. An especially creepy moment is when Gerry borrows Annabelle’s appearance to describe a girlfriend he is going to phone. The similarity is too subtle for Richard to notice, but the words used echo the narrator’s description perfectly.

So, how 1958ish is Hide My Eyes? I thought this comic incident, which takes place inside a barber’s shop, had a great sense of entering a forgotten world that we probably don’t remember forgetting. Anyone discussed the correct time recently? It is, by the way, central to Hawker’s modus operandi.

‘What is the time exactly?’
The question turned out to be amazingly popular with everybody. Mr Vick turned at once to point to the flyblown disc on the wall behind him.
‘That clock is dead right by the Shakespeare Head long bar, slow by Ronnie’s next door, and fast by the B.B.C.,’ he announced with incomprehensible pride.
‘It is four minutes and twenty-three – don’t stop me, twenty-four, twenty-five seconds fast pre-cisely,’ said the sporting salesman, looking at his wristwatch, an impressive performance which he offset somewhat by adjusting the instrument immediately.
‘Wait,’ commanded the fat man, heaving himself up and accomplishing vasty manoeuvres under is shrouding cape. ‘This is the right time. This is the real time. Railway time, that’s what this is.’ He brought out a large silver pocket watch, looked at it earnestly for some moments, shook it, and put it back. ‘You’re not far out,’ he said to the barber.

Not a scene an author could write now, but not especially specific to the late ’50s. This is more like it:

‘Luke finds it absorbing even though he can’t hang ’em any more.’
His friend’s face became a shade blacker.
‘That’s not a very popular line of talk, Cully,’ he was beginning when Donne ventured to reply for himself.
‘We’ll hang the chap we’re after now all right,’ he said.
‘Think so?’ Luke sounded spiteful. ‘At the moment I’m wondering if we have enough evidence to bring him to trial… If under the new regulations we’ve got to see him sentenced twice before he’s eligible he may well escape topping. I can’t see the public standing for two trials for murder, first conviction no hanging, the second it’s laid on.’

I assume this is a reference to the 1957 Homicide Act, which seems to have made to harder to execute murderers, although I can’t see the relevant provisions in the Wikipedia article. (One of the less appealing aspects of Luke is his enthusiasm for topping killers, as seen in The Tiger in the Smoke.)

So there we have it – a great piece of suspense writing, less broad in its scope than The Tiger in the Smoke, but possibly better in its evocation of the banality of evil.

See also:

The Passing TrampWhat’s your favorite Margery Allingham crime novel?  It’s been de rigueur for some time now to say The Tiger in the Smoke (1952), but, truth be told, that one’s not mine.

HeavenaliAllingham’s details of London streets, the inhabitants of Garden Green, and  the odd little house and museum which are at the centre of the story – are brilliantly evocative.

A Pile of LeavesChapter on chapter, page on page, we’re drawn deeper into the story, into this circle of strangers who, you’d think, have nothing in common. Deeper and deeper into that quiet London square, into the house with a queer museum of odd artefacts in it, up the stairs to the room with the gas fire and the big Chinese vase. It was quite impossible to set aside, even when I had to close the book – the novel was always purring along in the back of my mind, waiting for me to go deeper in.


About pastoffences

Past Offences exists to review classic crime and mystery books, with ‘classic’ meaning books originally published before 1987.
This entry was posted in Classic mystery book review, Crime fiction of the year challenge, Golden Age detection, Margery Allingham, Suspense, Witness Statements and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

18 Responses to Margery Allingham’s Hide My Eyes

  1. Great choice for this vintage Rich – which reminds me that I must re-read it as I think it’s been a good 25 years since I first read this (yes, when the TV show started basically)


  2. heavenali says:

    It’s three years since I read this and I am ashamed to say I have forgotten almost all the plot though I remember Garden Green and the phone line being installed rings a bell (oops no pun intended). Excellent review and thanks for linking to my brief thoughts of three years ago.


  3. Margot Kinberg says:

    Excellent review as ever, Rich. And a good reminder that I really ought to pick up on some of the Allinghams I’ve not (yet) read.


  4. realthog says:

    An excellent piece of reviewing and a reminder that I must start rereading the Allinghams sometime soon.


  5. I thought I’d read all of Allingham (some of them a very long time ago) but I think perhaps I missed this one: it sounds like a must-read in a nasty kind of way, and it’s not ringing any bells. Great review. I like your look at which bits are specific to 1958…


  6. Skywatcher says:

    It’s an excellent book, although I have to agree that this is only nominally a Campion book. Luke was a really vivid creation, and I’ve always suspected that if she had been able to get away with it she would have made it a ‘Charlie Luke’ novel rather than an ‘Albert Campion’ one. It’s interesting that when she wrote this book the Police Procedurals of Creasey and McBain were starting to become popular. If she hadn’t been stricken by ill health, you have to wonder whether she would ultimately have moved fully into the genre.


    • westwoodrich says:

      I think I’m going on to The China Governess next – another one with Charlie Luke to the fore, although I’m hazy on the details. And then we get on to The Mind Readers, of which the less said the better, and Cargo of Eagles, both of which you could argue show more of an inclination towards espionage. She seemed to get quite experimental towards the end of her career.


  7. Albert says:

    Hide My Eyes is the English title. The American title is Tether’s End. I think John reviewed this title a few months ago also.


  8. Juxtabook says:

    Lovely review. Your reviews always are brilliant and I’m sorry that I don’t make time to comment on them more often. I love the perspective you always give your reviews, the pick-a-year thing you run helps (and I enjoyed both your era quotes on this one) but it is your staggering knowledge of the genre that really does it. Not only do I always enjoy your posts, I always learn something. Thank you!


  9. Keishon says:

    I REALLY must read this writer. Thanks.


  10. Pingback: The Mystery of the Missing Twins: #1958book | Past Offences Classic Crime Fiction

  11. Pingback: September 2014: Pick of the month | Past Offences Classic Crime Fiction

  12. Pingback: 2014 Vintage Mystery Reading Challenge – status update | Past Offences Classic Crime Fiction

  13. Pingback: Ed. Martin Edwards: Capital Crimes | Past Offences Classic Crime Fiction

  14. Pingback: Margery Allingham: Sweet Danger | Past Offences: Classic crime, thrillers and mystery book reviews

Make a statement...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s