Ed McBain: Cop Hater

Cop HaterCop Hater
Ed McBain
First published in the US,  1956, Permabooks
This edition Orion Books, 2003
ISBN: 9780752857916
188 pages

The buildings were a stage-set.
They faced the river, and they glowed with man-made brilliance, and you stared up at them in awe, and you caught your breath.
Behind the buildings, behind the lights, were the streets.
There was garbage in the streets.

Cop Hater was the first of more than 50 87th Precinct novels by Ed McBain. The 87th Precinct covers a large area of the American city of Isola and is the setting for one of the earliest, most influential, and certainly the longest running, police-procedural series in crime fiction.

(In an engaging introduction to this edition, McBain explains that he intended to set Cop Hater in New York, but was finding the overhead of checking every single piece of procedure onerous, so switched to his own city. Doing so clearly opened his creative floodgates – two more 87th Precinct novels followed in 1956.)

If you’ve read any of the novels, you’ll know that the hard-working cops of Isola are very rarely lucky with the weather. It’s so cold you can barely move your frozen limbs to arrest your perp, or so wet you can’t see him through the rain. In Cop Hater, it’s hot, 95.6°F of hot:

At the precinct house, two fans circulated the soggy air that crawled past the open windows and the grilles behind them. Everything in the Detective Squad Room seemed to wilt under the steady, malignant pressure of the heat. Only the file cabinets and the desks stood at strict attention.

And in this horrible damp heat, somebody starts killing detectives. The Squad Room starts chasing suspects – sweatily, and with plenty of stops for beer.

Bush, an experienced but cynical cop, sums up McBain’s philosophy of detection early on:

All you need to be a detective is a strong pair of legs, and a stubborn streak. The legs take you around to all the various dumps you have to go to, and the stubborn streak keeps you from quitting. You follow each separate trail mechanically, and if you’re lucky, one of the trails pays off. If you’re not lucky, it doesn’t. Period.

And this is how it goes. The cops follow up leads – most of them dead ends – meanwhile dealing with reporters, crazies, assorted criminals, and all the inefficiencies of an imperfect and cumbersome system.  This is the cop as working stiff, bitching about the job and the weather (especially the weather) but getting the job done.

There is no shortage of leads. Bush again:

This whole goddamn city is full of cop haters. You think anybody respects a cop? Symbol of law and order, crap! Anybody who ever got a parking tag is automatically a cop hater. That’s the way it is.

As with more recent authors, McBain also offers us a glimpse into the private lives of his policemen as a counterpoint to their lives at the coalface. Detective Steve Carella (a mainstay of the series) gets together with his wife Teddy, while his partner Bush deals with his complicated marriage to the négligée-clad Alice.

The atmosphere of Cop Hater seems strikingly contemporary, aside from all the men wearing suits, the ladies’ underwear (there’s almost as much underwear as there is weather), and a couple of chapters featuring hep-cat gang members. It’s almost surprising it was published in 1956. Of course the book feels contemporary – timeless may be a better word – because it uses exactly that mix of bureaucracy and banter that characterises police novels today. In fact, McBain established that formula and proved it worked again and again.

Why should you read this book? It established the template for the modern police procedural, and more importantly, if you like it, there are dozens more in the series to keep you going.

I’ll leave you with today’s weather:

The heat did not help the classic ceremonies of death. The mourners followed the caskets and sweated. An evil, leering sun grinned its blistering grin, and freshly turned soil – which should have been cool and moist – accepted the caskets with dry, dusty indifference.

See also: Sadie When She Died, Gideon’s Day (for a UK equivalent). Sergio at Tipping my Fedora is reading the 87th Precinct novels in order.

I am entering Cop Hater into the Vintage Mystery Reading Challenge, in the Leave it to the Professionals category.

Final destination: A keeper

Creative Commons License
Past Offences by Rich Westwood is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.

About pastoffences

Past Offences exists to review classic crime and mystery books, with ‘classic’ meaning books originally published before 1987.
This entry was posted in Classic mystery book review, Police procedural, Pulp, Witness Statements and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to Ed McBain: Cop Hater

  1. Pingback: The Vintage Mystery Reading Challenge | Past Offences

  2. Margot Kinberg says:

    Rich – A fine review, for which thanks. This series, to me, is a classic. It really set the tone for the modern police procedural (well, especially the American police procedural. I’ve always liked the ensemble approach to crime solving; it strikes me as realistic. And this story set the tone for Steve Carella’s character I think (although he does evolve over time).


  3. Really enjoyed the review Rich, especially because I think your opinions really chime with mine – one of us must be right!


  4. I adore the McBains and I agree that they really set the standard for the police procedurals. I’ve read them all and the early ones are definitely better. But they’re all wonderful ensemble pieces and McBain’s writing is superb – economic but atmospheric. Great stuff!


  5. Curtis Evans says:

    “Economic and atmospheric”–that does describe it. I wish more modern authors realized that narrative economy is compatible with atmosphere.


  6. What a coincidence, I just read this one myself, and had similar feelings about it. Great review. I’ve been really enjoying the series and highly recommend most if not all of the books.


  7. gaskella says:

    So far this is only 87th precinct novel I’ve read – but I have a dozen on the shelves. I must get round to reading some more as I very much enjoyed Cop Hater – ground-breaking in it’s portrayal of the police-procedural. It reminded me of NYPD Blue in that respect.


  8. Pingback: Crime fiction pick of the month: June 2013 | Past Offences

  9. Pingback: Review: Cop Hater by Ed McBain | The Game's Afoot

  10. Pingback: ‘We’re wonderfully highly mechanised at Central Office these days, Campion.’ Margery Allingham’s The Tiger in the Smoke | Past Offences: Classic crime, thrillers and mystery book reviews

Make a statement...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s