Eric Shepherd: Murder in a Nunnery


‘When Inez first came to us she would have thought no more of stabbing than of washing her face. In fact she would have thought considerably less.’

Murder in a Nunnery is an affectionate portrait of matter-of-fact entirely unsheltered nuns and sensation-hungry schoolgirls – none of whom is particularly phased by a murder in their midst.

Madame Sliema is a nasty old lady seeing out her final years in Harrington Convent, practising her malice on a put-upon companion, a young ward and a distant son who is kept on a pittance. When she is stabbed there is a general lack of grief and precious little surprise. The nuns certainly take matters in their stride, surprising the police with their cool heads and lack of awe.

The Detective-Sergeant, Police-Surgeon Goodall and several constables left by car for the Convent.
But if these gentlemen had been disposed to find something funny in the idea of murder in a Nunnery, they were soon called to order and made to think very differently when they encountered Mother Peck, the portress, at the door. Mother Peck looked them over with a sharp and blighting eye, dwelling particularly on their feet – and then interned them in small and hideous parlour designed to break the contentious spirit of visiting parents. Here she left them – with a supply of CTS tracts – until, as she put it, “someone had time to attend to them.”


The chief investigator is Inspector Pearson, notable for his politeness and meekness (he is definitely inheriting the earth). He rapidly becomes a favourite with both nuns and students, who regard him as a ‘pet lamb’. For a policeman he is definitely unworldly – the worst thing that happens to him in the course of the book is entering a lady’s bedroom at night.

Never before in all his professional life had he lurked outside the bedroom door of a young and attractive girl. He had never felt the urge. He did not feel it now, quite the contrary.

At 164 pages, this is a very light read and might be best purchased with its sequel, More Murder in a Nunnery (of which, more soon).

Eric Shepherd
Murder in a Nunnery
First published in the UK by Sheed & Ward, 1940
This edition Ostara Publishing
Source: Publisher review copy (thanks Ostara!)
ISBN: 9781909619388
164 pages

See also:

Underground Reading: Chief Inspector Pearson, the book’s detective, is the major source of this particularly laid-back investigation. He’s so wonderfully British that his tea practically sips itself (and then apologizes profusely for the inconvenience). He meanders happily from one corner of the convent to the other, lingering over breakfast, chatting with the gardeners and only really getting worked up when one of his patrolmen fails to hold the door open for the ladies.

Pretty Sinister BooksMurder in a Nunnery (1940) was quite the sleeper when it was first published. Though published by small press Sheed & Ward it managed to get picked up by the Catholic Book Club in 1940 and turned into a minor sensation. Twenty two years later it was reprinted as a paperback from Dell’s Chapel Books imprint and sold thousands of more copies.

About pastoffences

Past Offences exists to review classic crime and mystery books, with ‘classic’ meaning books originally published before 1987.
This entry was posted in Golden Age detection, Witness Statements and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Eric Shepherd: Murder in a Nunnery

  1. I actually came across this book today on my internet travels, so your review is well timed. Didn’t realise it was published so early.


  2. Definitely one I want to read! Oh dear, the list is getting longer…


  3. Love the sound of this and look forward to hearing about the sequel Rich -ta!


  4. Sounds fun – a closed setting is always good for murder mysteries.


  5. John says:

    Bit of trivia unveiled on my blog in the comments: Frequent mystery blog visitor/reader/commenter Lucy Fisher has a brush with fame with Eric Shepherd Her mother was the inspiration for Verity. Her mother attended the Catholic school where Shepherd was a teacher in the 1930s.

    Looks like you’re going to beat me to the review of the sequel. Though I’ve had the book since this summer and was hoping to get to it before the end of 2016 I never did. I had no idea that both books had been reprinted until copies of each arrived in my mail just before Christmas. It was a nice surprise to discover that once again a book I enjoyed, raved over and hoped many more would read is available in a new edition.

    Liked by 2 people

  6. This sounds unmissable for me, I do love a book with nuns. and valuable extra info from Lucy! All round winner.


  7. bill kelly says:

    Screenwriter Emmet Lavery dramatized Murder in a Nunnery and directed the first production at the Wilshire Ebell Theatre in Los Angeles in 1942. Samuel French published the script in 1944.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. Pingback: Eric Shepherd: More Murder in a Nunnery | Past Offences: Classic crime, thrillers and mystery book reviews

Make a statement...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s